|
|
non-empty.png (75,086 bytes) |
|
|
The same staleness problem on the dev tools page also applies to other buttons, like I clicked on "delete" and the exchange I deleted didn't go away -- until I reloaded the page. |
|
|
first part, about the button not updating the UI screen, is fixed |
|
|
I now have CHF from both the BFH exchange and the TOPS exchange in my wallet. However, even after I selected the TOPS exchange explicitly, I cannot 'send' CHF from the TOPS exchange as it ALWAYS then picks the BFH exchange. So it only matches by currency, and not by the *selected* exchange! Very bad blocker for my demo today :-( |
|
|
added a new balance UI selector 6006fc80d..5d804540d |
|
|
in this setup i have 2 exchanges with currency LAIA (one is global and the other is regional) the regional currencies are under the domain name of the exchange Screenshot_2025-05-27_17-03-27-2.png (56,855 bytes) |
|
|
FTR only the currency is clickable, but exchanage scope is under a grouped using the exchange URL. I'm limited to use optgroup here [1] otherwise i will need to rewrite the full select box. [1] https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/Reference/Elements/optgroup |
|
|
I'm not sure this makes sense. You're now obscuring the exchange URL for the global currency. Sure, it's less relevant in that case, but it might confuse the user to NOT see it in that case. I'm also not sure the grouped using exchange URL is ideal. My suggestion: put everythign in one line ("CHF via exchange.taler-ops.ch") and maybe use bold-face for global currencies (just on the "CHF", so "CHF/b> via exchange.taler-ops.ch") to visually distinguish them. |
|
|
Wallet 1.0.12 still fails to honor the exchange selection when trying to initiate a P2P transfer if there are multiple exchanges for the same currency. |
|
|
I found the problem why is not using the correct scope |
|
|
d3948b0d8..21a196769 |
|
|
I changed the way you suggedted, what I don't like is the fact that <option> doesn't allow css customization (and I want to avoid refactoring the <select /> component) and doesn't work. Using <optgroup /> looks nicer. Grouping by currency is reasonable but when the value is selected you see the URL instead of the currency which is not want I want. I want to see the currency in this selector. For clarification, when the scope is not global a small text below the currency is show up to indicate that this is regional currency, global scoped currencies doesn't show the exchange base_url. image.png (30,069 bytes) image-2.png (29,197 bytes) |
|
|
Ah, didn't realize formatting inside was not supported. I guess grouping by currency and then selecting the exchange does actually make sense --- after all, that gives you first the main choice (which currency) and then nicely (and without redundancy) gives you what you are actually selecting: the exchanges for that currency. So I could live with a list of exchanges grouped by currency where one always has to select a currency. The question is then how to indicate nicely (for 3-letter currencies) that an exchange is not in the "approved" set. Maybe: "unknown provider, risky" might work? |
|
|
What you are seeing is the list of scope, so - global scopes will be shown without url (you will see the history of all transactions related to all approved exchanges for this currency) - exchange scoped will be shown with the exchange url (this are non-approved exchanges) I'm adding 4 screens how it looks for your suggestion. There are two exchanges that share the same currency name. 1) when non of the exchange are approved 2) when only one LAIA exchange is approved 3) when both LAIA exchanges are approved 4) when all exchanges are approved the last screenshot you can see how it looks when the Exchange scope is selected. I can't change this, is the limitation of the <select />. Grouping by exchange URL (as my first example) look better when the option is selected because it will render the currency name and the url will be below. image-3.png (62,327 bytes) image-4.png (59,169 bytes) image-5.png (56,020 bytes) image-6.png (56,070 bytes) image-7.png (55,308 bytes) |
|
|
I'm pushing the last example, unless other indication. And this issue can't be resolved until the child is resolved first. |
|
|
No, that last one is still not OK. When the menu is not expanded, it fails to show the currency at all. Suggestion: why not show the currency in a dynamic (non-editable) text field between the drop-down and the number? So we'd have [exchange dropdown] $CURRENCY $NUMBER (or conceivably [exchange dropdown] $NUMBER $CURRENCY depending on locale). The $CURRENCY would, like $NUMBER not be editable. Also, I see no point in then still putting the exchange domain name under the drop-down, it's now redundant. Vlada: opinions welcome! |
|
|
For a good comparison, this is the same screenshot in but using my first suggested implementation. 1) when non of the exchange are approved 2) when only one LAIA exchange is approved 3) when both LAIA exchanges are approved 4) when all exchanges are approved 5) when selected, only the currency is shown. > Suggestion: why not show the currency in a dynamic (non-editable) text field between the drop-down and the number? it's not a exchange dropdown, you have also global currencies so we could use mix both but I think that's not nice. The closer to that is usign the dropdown to show currency AND exchange (design 2) but also not perfect. image-8.png (59,466 bytes) image-9.png (57,301 bytes) image-10.png (55,778 bytes) image-11.png (52,475 bytes) image-12.png (26,785 bytes) |
|
|
1) Only one exchange is available for selected currency 2) Possibility for difference views for user 3) Selected exchange is not trusted by developers. On icon hover, show hint "The developers of this wallet do not trust this service provider." picture from penpot https://penpot.taler.net/#/workspace?team-id=826af720-982c-8096-8006-0dbdd6a758c1&file-id=29e68e1b-4b36-81a2-8006-436e5512dd51&page-id=29e68e1b-4b36-81a2-8006-436e5512dd52 I think separating currencies and exchanges to different dropdowns might be clearer for users Board.png (34,463 bytes) |
|
|
I don't think exposing here a list of exchanges is a good idea. The dropdown is about balance scopes https://docs.taler.net/design-documents/035-regional-currencies.html The exchange URL is only shown when the transactions and money is not REAL money (an exchange need to be approved by an authority to be able to be listed in the wallet as provider of official currency) |
- Anonymous
